The Absolute Best Pie in Colorado Springs [Updated 2024]

With a whopping 15 pie places under my belt, I have scoured the streets of Colorado Springs in search of the most delectable, melt-in-your-mouth creations. From classic apple pie to exotic flavors like lavender honey, I have tasted them all.

So, whether you're a local or just passing through, get ready for a mouthwatering adventure. In this article, I will reveal the hidden gems and all-time favorites that will satisfy even the most discerning pie connoisseur.

Join me as we explore the tantalizing world of pie in Colorado Springs, where every slice promises a blissful indulgence.

Gold Star Bakery

Highlights
Delicious!
Instant hit!
Highly recommend

From the moment I walked into Gold Star Bakery, the aroma of freshly baked pies filled the air, setting the stage for what turned out to be an instant hit for my taste buds.

The first slice I tried was their classic apple pie. The crust was perfectly flaky and buttery, providing a delightful contrast to the tender and cinnamon-spiced apple filling. Each bite was a symphony of flavors that made my taste buds dance with joy.

Next, I indulged in their decadent chocolate cream pie. The smooth and velvety chocolate filling was heaven for any chocolate lover. The crust, with its rich cocoa undertones, added an extra layer of deliciousness to the experience.

To my surprise, Gold Star Bakery also offers a unique twist on the traditional pie - their blueberry basil pie. The combination of sweet blueberries and aromatic basil created a taste sensation that I had never encountered before. It was a bold and unexpected blend of flavors that worked in perfect harmony.

Overall, I highly recommend Gold Star Bakery for their delicious and innovative pies. Whether you're a fan of the classics or looking for something more adventurous, this bakery has something to satisfy every pie lover's cravings. So, if you find yourself in Colorado Springs, make sure to stop by Gold Star Bakery and indulge in their delectable creations. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Denver.

Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders

Highlights
Fantastic pizza
Great service
Attention to quality control
Easy online ordering
Will definitely return

Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders is a delightful little gem that truly lives up to its name. As soon as I stepped inside, the inviting aroma of fresh-baked pies wafted through the air, immediately capturing my attention.

The first thing that struck me about this place was the fantastic pizza they offer. Although I came for the pie, I couldn't help but indulge in a slice of their mouthwatering pizza. Every bite was a burst of flavors, with a thin and crispy crust that was perfectly seasoned. It was truly a treat!

The great service was another aspect that stood out during my visit. The staff was friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about their pies. They seemed genuinely passionate about what they do, which translated into a warm and welcoming atmosphere.

What impressed me the most was their meticulous attention to quality control. From the first bite to the last, every pie maintained consistent quality, with a flaky and buttery crust that simply melted in my mouth. Each flavor combination was carefully crafted and well-balanced, leaving me eager to savor the next bite.

In this modern age of convenience, Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders has made it even easier with their easy online ordering system. I appreciated the convenience, as it allowed me to order my favorite pies with just a few clicks and have them ready for pickup.

Overall, my experience at Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders was nothing short of delightful, and I will definitely return. Whether you're a pie connoisseur or just looking for a delicious treat, I highly recommend giving this charming establishment a visit. Their pies are a delightful indulgence that will surely leave you craving more.

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Denver.

Garden of the Gods Market and Cafe

Highlights
Fantastic service
Knowledgeable and helpful staff
Fresh and delicious food
Variety of wine options
Clean and organized establishment

Let me just start by saying, this place has some fantastic service. The staff is not only knowledgeable and helpful, but they go above and beyond to make sure you have a delightful experience. Whether you're a pie enthusiast or not, they'll make you feel right at home.

Now let's talk about the pies. Oh boy, they are out of this world! The moment I took my first bite, I knew I had stumbled upon something special. The pies here are fresh and delicious. Each slice is a slice of heaven. From classic apple pie to unique flavor combinations, they have it all. You won't be disappointed.

But wait, there's more! Garden of the Gods Market and Cafe also offers a variety of wine options to pair with your scrumptious pie. So, if you're feeling a little fancy, go ahead and indulge in the perfect wine-pie combo.

One thing that truly impressed me was the cleanliness and organization of the establishment. It's clear they take pride in their work and strive to provide a top-notch experience. From the moment you walk in, you'll feel welcomed and at ease.

In conclusion, if you're on a quest for the best pie in Colorado Springs, look no further than Garden of the Gods Market and Cafe. With exceptional service, mouthwatering pies, a great wine selection, and an overall pleasant atmosphere, this place should be at the top of your pie-loving bucket list.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Vail.

Sweet Elizabeth's Organics

Highlights
Everything is delicious
Consistently excellent quality
Kind and fun staff
Healthy and flavorful options
Go-to place for delicious healthy food

Let me start by saying that at Sweet Elizabeth's Organics, everything is delicious. I sampled a variety of their pies, and each one was a tasty masterpiece. From the crust to the filling, the quality was consistently excellent. The attention to detail in the presentation was impressive, making each slice look like a work of art.

But it's not just the pies that make this place special. The staff at Sweet Elizabeth's Organics is kind and fun, adding to the overall enjoyable experience. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, you'll feel welcomed and appreciated. They genuinely care about their customers and go above and beyond to make sure you leave with a smile.

One thing that sets Sweet Elizabeth's Organics apart from other pie places is their commitment to healthy and flavorful options. Their ingredients are fresh and organic, and they offer a range of dietary options to cater to various needs. You can indulge in a delicious slice of pie without feeling guilty.

In conclusion, Sweet Elizabeth's Organics is truly a go-to place for delicious and healthy food in Colorado Springs. The pies are a standout, but the overall experience is what makes it memorable. If you're looking for a place that combines excellent quality, friendly service, and delectable treats, look no further than Sweet Elizabeth's Organics.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Denver.

Benne's Sweet Treats

Highlights
Delicious cupcakes
Fresh and moist
Attention to detail
Great flavor
Top tier baked goods

Benne's Sweet Treats in Colorado Springs is a delightful bakery that offers a wide array of baked goods. While their specialty is cupcakes, their pies certainly don't disappoint. From the first bite, it was clear that this establishment takes their craft seriously.

The pies at Benne's Sweet Treats are a testament to the dedication and attention to detail of their talented bakers. Each slice is filled with a medley of delicious flavors that will leave you wanting more. The crust is perfectly flaky, providing a satisfying crunch that complements the smooth and luscious filling.

What sets Benne's Sweet Treats apart from other pie shops is their commitment to using fresh and high-quality ingredients. The pies are made with love, and it shows in every bite. The combination of top-tier ingredients and the bakers' expertise results in a pie that is moist, flavorful, and simply irresistible.

The variety of flavors available at Benne's Sweet Treats is impressive, catering to all taste buds. Whether you're a fan of classic apple or prefer more unique flavors like salted caramel or berry blend, you're sure to find something that will satisfy your cravings.

Overall, Benne's Sweet Treats is a hidden gem in Colorado Springs that deserves recognition for their outstanding pies. With their dedication to delivering top-notch pies that are both visually appealing and heavenly in taste, they are a must-visit for any pie enthusiast.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Colorado Springs.

La Baguette

Highlights
Delectable French sandwiches
Cheesecake Fruit Tart
Centrally located in Old Colorado City
Fresh ingredients
Perfection pastries

First of all, let me begin by saying that La Baguette is truly a hidden gem when it comes to pie in Colorado Springs. Nestled in the heart of Old Colorado City, this delightful bakery and café offers a delightful array of pastries, and their pies are no exception.

Upon entering La Baguette, I was immediately drawn to the display case showcasing their impressive selection of pies. From classic favorites to unique creations, they had something to satisfy every pie lover’s cravings. I opted to try their Cheesecake Fruit Tart, and let me tell you, it was a taste of heaven. The combination of creamy cheesecake and a medley of fresh, juicy fruits was simply divine.

What impressed me the most about La Baguette was not just the exceptional quality of their pies, but also the attention to detail in each one. From the flaky crust to the deliciously balanced fillings, it was clear that they use only the freshest ingredients. Every bite was a delight, leaving me craving for more.

Besides their incredible pie selection, La Baguette also offers an array of delectable French sandwiches and other pastry options. The pastries were nothing short of perfection, with each bite transporting me to the streets of Paris.

If you find yourself in Colorado Springs and in desperate need of a slice of pie, you cannot go wrong with a visit to La Baguette. Trust me, their pies are worth the trip. So, indulge your taste buds and treat yourself to a slice of perfection at La Baguette. Bon appétit!

You might also want to check out the best burger in Colorado Springs.

Icing on the Cake

Highlights
Exceeds expectations
Beautiful and moist
Friendly and affordable
Multiple flavors

I have to say, Icing on the Cake truly exceeded my expectations when it came to their pies. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm and friendly atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The staff were incredibly knowledgeable and helpful, making it easy to choose from the wide variety of flavors they had available.

I can confidently say that the pies at Icing on the Cake are not just visually appealing, but also delightfully moist and flavorful. Each bite was a tantalizing explosion of taste, leaving me craving more. The crust was perfectly baked, providing a buttery and flaky base to complement the filling.

What I loved most about Icing on the Cake was the array of flavors they offer. Whether you're a fan of traditional classics like apple and pumpkin, or prefer something more adventurous like key lime or chocolate pecan, they have something for everyone. You can truly taste the love and care that goes into each pie.

Another standout feature of Icing on the Cake is their affordability. Despite the high-quality ingredients and craftsmanship that goes into every pie, the prices are surprisingly reasonable. It's refreshing to find a bakery that values both taste and affordability.

In conclusion, Icing on the Cake in Colorado Springs is a must-visit for pie enthusiasts. Their pies exceed expectations in taste, with a beautiful and moist texture that will leave you wanting more. The friendly and affordable atmosphere, coupled with the wide range of flavors, makes it a delightful experience for all pie lovers.

You might also want to check out the best pho in Denver.

Mary's Mountain Cookies

Highlights
Wide variety
Gluten free
Monster cookies
Best deal
Large size

First and foremost, let me tell you that Mary's Mountain Cookies does not only specialize in cookies, they also offer an impressive selection of pies that will surely leave you wanting more. One of the things that stood out to me about this bakery is their wide variety of pie flavors. From classic choices like apple and cherry to more unique options like coconut cream and key lime, there is something to satisfy every palate.

Furthermore, Mary's Mountain Cookies caters to those with dietary restrictions by offering gluten-free pies. This attention to inclusivity sets them apart from other pie shops in Colorado Springs, as they ensure that everyone can enjoy their delectable creations.

Now, let's talk about the monster cookies! These massive treats are a must-try when visiting Mary's Mountain Cookies. With their generous size and loaded with delicious ingredients like chocolate chips and nuts, these cookies are indulgence at its finest.

Not only are their pies and cookies mouthwatering, but Mary's Mountain Cookies also offers the best deal in town. The prices are incredibly reasonable for the quality and portion sizes you receive. You won't find a better value anywhere else.

In conclusion, if you find yourself in Colorado Springs and are craving a delightful pie experience, Mary's Mountain Cookies should be at the top of your list. With their wide variety of flavors, including gluten-free options, their mouthwatering monster cookies, and unbeatable prices, you won't be disappointed. So grab a slice of pie, indulge your sweet tooth, and enjoy the deliciousness that Mary's Mountain Cookies has to offer!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Vail Village.

3.14 Pi Bar

Highlights
Delicious pies
Friendly staff
Great sweet pies
Unique bar food

Let me start off by saying that 3.14 Pi Bar knows how to bake delicious pies. From the moment I walked into the cozy and inviting atmosphere, I could already smell the sweet aromas of their freshly baked creations.

The staff at 3.14 Pi Bar are not only knowledgeable about their pies, but they are also incredibly friendly. They greeted me with a warm smile and were eager to assist me in making the best pie selection.

Now, let's talk about the main event - the pies! Oh boy, were they fantastic. Each bite was a delightful explosion of flavors. Whether you have a craving for a classic apple pie or want to try something more adventurous like their unique pie flavors, 3.14 Pi Bar has got you covered.

What sets 3.14 Pi Bar apart from other pie places in Colorado Springs is their ability to also serve up great sweet pies alongside some unique bar food. It's the perfect place to satisfy your late-night cravings with a slice of pie and a side of their mouthwatering bar snacks.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best pie in Colorado Springs, I highly recommend checking out 3.14 Pi Bar. Their delicious pies, friendly staff, and unique bar food make for an unforgettable pie experience. Don't just take my word for it – go and experience it for yourself!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Denver.

Boonzaaijer's Dutch Bakery

Highlights
Best bakery in town
Friendly and helpful staff
Amazing coffee
Reasonable prices
Top notch customer service

Let me start by saying that Boonzaaijer's Dutch Bakery is truly the best bakery in town when it comes to pies. As soon as I walked in, the delicious aroma of freshly baked goods hit me. It was impossible to resist the temptation!

The staff at Boonzaaijer's is not only friendly and helpful, but they are also true experts in their craft. They guided me through their extensive selection of pies, showcasing their knowledge and passion for baking.

While the pies at Boonzaaijer's are undeniably the star of the show, I was pleasantly surprised by their amazing coffee. It paired perfectly with the slices of heaven in front of me.

What sets Boonzaaijer's apart from the rest is their commitment to providing exceptional quality at reasonable prices. Each bite was worth every penny, and I left feeling completely satisfied.

The top-notch customer service at Boonzaaijer's deserves a mention as well. The staff went above and beyond to ensure that I had the best experience possible.

In conclusion, if you find yourself in Colorado Springs and crave a delectable pie, make sure to visit Boonzaaijer's Dutch Bakery. With their mouthwatering pies, friendly staff, delicious coffee, reasonable prices, and exceptional customer service, it's no wonder they have earned the title of the best pie in town.

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Denver.

Perkins Restaurant & Bakery

Highlights
Great service
Relaxing atmosphere
Tons of food
Wonderful place to eat
Kind and accommodating staff

First and foremost, let me start by saying that the service at Perkins Restaurant & Bakery is absolutely top-notch. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile and a genuine willingness to make my experience as enjoyable as possible. The staff here is truly kind and accommodating, going above and beyond to ensure that every customer feels welcomed and satisfied.

The atmosphere of Perkins is also worth mentioning. It is a relaxing and inviting place, perfect for a cozy afternoon indulging in some delicious pie. Whether you're dining alone or with a group of friends, you'll instantly feel at ease in this wonderful establishment.

Now, let's talk about the food. When it comes to pies, Perkins has got it nailed. Their selection is extensive, offering a wide variety of flavors to choose from. From classic favorites like apple and cherry to more unique options like key lime and chocolate silk, there is truly something for everyone's taste buds.

And let me tell you, the portions at Perkins are no joke. When they say "tons of food," they mean it. A single slice of pie is enough to satisfy even the heartiest of appetites. So make sure to come hungry and ready to indulge in a truly indulgent dessert experience.

In conclusion, if you're in Colorado Springs and on the hunt for the best pie in town, look no further than Perkins Restaurant & Bakery. Their great service, relaxing atmosphere, and mouthwatering pies make it a must-visit for any pie lover. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

Marigold Cafe & Bakery

Highlights
Birthday celebration
Fast service
Delicious desserts
Lovely service
Knowledgeable server

Marigold Cafe & Bakery in Colorado Springs is a dazzling gem when it comes to mouthwatering pies. As soon as I stepped foot into the charming café, I was greeted with warm smiles and a cozy atmosphere that made me feel right at home.

I had the pleasure of celebrating my birthday there, and I must say, it was a delightful experience from start to finish. The fast and efficient service ensured that my party and I were well taken care of throughout the evening.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show—the pies! Marigold Cafe & Bakery offers a delectable selection of delicious desserts that are guaranteed to leave your taste buds dancing with joy. The flaky crusts and perfectly balanced fillings were simply divine. Each slice was a harmonious blend of flavors that would make any pie connoisseur weak in the knees.

What truly elevated my experience at Marigold Cafe & Bakery was the attentive and lovely service provided by the staff. Our knowledgeable server guided us through the impressive array of pies and offered insightful recommendations based on our preferences. It was evident that the staff's passion for their craft translated into each delectable bite.

If you find yourself in Colorado Springs, I highly recommend a visit to Marigold Cafe & Bakery for an unforgettable pie experience. Trust me, this hidden gem is a slice of heaven that will leave you craving more.

Mountain Pie CO

Highlights
Unique flavors
Authentic Meat Pie
Fresh and savory
Homemade chutney mustard
Great at Heritage Brew Festival

Mountain Pie CO in Colorado Springs is a hidden gem for pie enthusiasts like me. This humble little pie shop offers an array of unique flavors that will make your taste buds dance with delight.

One thing that immediately caught my attention was their authentic meat pie. Made with love and attention to detail, this savory delight is a carnivore's dream. The flaky crust gives way to a juicy filling bursting with flavor. Each bite is like a warm and comforting hug for your palate.

What sets Mountain Pie CO apart from other pie shops is their commitment to using fresh and high-quality ingredients. It's evident in every bite. The pies are made with local produce and their own special blend of spices, resulting in a taste that is unparalleled.

One of the highlights of my visit was trying their homemade chutney mustard. This condiment is the perfect accompaniment to the pies, adding a tangy and slightly spicy kick that elevates the flavor profile to new heights.

I also had the pleasure of enjoying their pies at the Heritage Brew Festival recently, where Mountain Pie CO showcased their creations alongside craft beer. The combination of their pies and local brews is nothing short of magical.

If you're in Colorado Springs and on the hunt for the best pie in town, look no further than Mountain Pie CO. Their unique flavors, authentic meat pies, fresh ingredients, and homemade condiments make for a truly exceptional pie experience. Don't miss out on this pie paradise.

White Pie Pizzeria

Highlights
Friendly and engaging staff
Outstanding Burrata with fresh toppings
Crisp outer crust on the Blondie pizza
Unique and delicious flavor combinations
Inviting outdoor seating area

White Pie Pizzeria in Colorado Springs is undoubtedly a hidden gem for all pie lovers out there. From the moment you step inside, you are warmly greeted by a friendly and engaging staff that sets the tone for a delightful dining experience.

One highlight of White Pie Pizzeria is their outstanding Burrata. This creamy, fresh cheese is perfectly complemented by a variety of toppings. With each bite, you can taste the dedication to quality and the careful selection of ingredients.

In addition to their classic pies, White Pie Pizzeria truly shines with their unique and delicious flavor combinations. Whether it's the unexpected yet delectable pairing of figs and prosciutto or the delightful blend of arugula and lemon vinaigrette, each bite is a flavor sensation that leaves you craving more.

The crisp outer crust on the Blondie pizza is particularly noteworthy. It provides a satisfying crunch with every bite, adding an extra layer of texture and flavor to the already tantalizing combination of toppings.

To top it all off, White Pie Pizzeria offers an inviting outdoor seating area that allows you to indulge in your pie while enjoying the Colorado Springs sunshine.

In conclusion, White Pie Pizzeria is a haven for pie enthusiasts. With their friendly staff, outstanding Burrata, unique flavor combinations, and inviting outdoor seating, it is truly a place worth visiting for an unmatched pie experience in Colorado Springs.

Norma’s Bakery

Highlights
Three Kings bread
Cheese-filled bread
Chocolate Motherlode Cake
Comparable to Claim Jumper
Wife approved

Let me start by saying that Norma’s Bakery is a hidden gem when it comes to exquisite pies in Colorado Springs. Upon entering this charming establishment, I was immediately greeted by the sweet aroma of freshly baked delights.

One of the first things that caught my eye was the impressive display of Three Kings bread, which instantly transported me to a European bakery. Its beautifully braided texture and subtle sweetness made it a true standout. Norma’s Bakery really knows how to create edible masterpieces.

As I continued my delightful exploration, I stumbled upon their cheese-filled bread. Oh, what a treat! The warm, gooey cheese oozing out of the fluffy bread was nothing short of heavenly. It truly was a cheese lover’s dream come true.

Now, let's talk about their pies. While Norma's Bakery doesn't specialize in pies, their Chocolate Motherlode Cake deserves a special mention. This decadent creation left me speechless. Each moist layer was generously coated with a rich chocolate ganache, ensuring that every bite was pure bliss.

Comparatively, Norma's Bakery is even on par with popular chain restaurants like Claim Jumper. Believe me when I say that their quality is unparalleled.

Lastly, I must mention that my dear wife, who has a discerning palate of her own, gave Norma’s Bakery her seal of approval. It's not easy to impress her when it comes to baked goods, but Norma's Bakery certainly did the trick.

In conclusion, if you are in search of delectable pies in Colorado Springs, Norma’s Bakery will pleasantly surprise you. With their mouthwatering Three Kings bread, gooey cheese-filled bread, and irresistible Chocolate Motherlode Cake, you won't be disappointed. Norma's Bakery is undoubtedly a must-visit destination for pie enthusiasts and dessert aficionados alike.