Keystone's Best Restaurants [Updated 2024]

My passion for food and extensive knowledge of the local dining scene have allowed me to review and curate the top 15 restaurants in Keystone. Throughout this article, I will take you on a culinary journey, highlighting the hidden gems and savor-worthy establishments that this charming mountain town has to offer.

Whether you crave sumptuous steaks, delectable seafood, or flavorful vegetarian dishes, Keystone's restaurant scene has something for every palate. From casual eateries with breathtaking mountain views to elegant dining experiences that will impress even the most discerning food connoisseur, this guide will ensure that you indulge in the finest gastronomic delights Keystone has to offer.

Lime - An American Cantina

Highlights
Good food
Fair prices
Happy Hour specials
Great service
Strong margs

Walking into Lime - An American Cantina in Keystone, I knew I was in for a treat. The vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff immediately caught my attention. As an avid foodie, I couldn't wait to dive into the menu and see what this place had to offer.

The first thing that impressed me was the variety of options available. From traditional American favorites to Mexican-inspired dishes, Lime truly caters to all taste buds. Whether you're in the mood for a classic burger or some mouthwatering tacos, Lime has got you covered.

One of the highlights of my visit was the quality of the food. Each dish was expertly prepared and bursting with flavor. From the first bite, it was evident that Lime takes pride in using fresh, high-quality ingredients. The presentation was also top-notch, making each plate a feast for the eyes as well as the taste buds.

What really set Lime apart from other restaurants in Keystone was its fair prices. Despite the exceptional quality of the food and the inviting ambiance, the prices were surprisingly reasonable. And if you happen to visit during Happy Hour, you'll be treated to even more savings with their fantastic specials.

I must also mention the incredible service at Lime. The staff went above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. They were attentive, knowledgeable, and always had a smile on their faces. It's clear that Lime places a strong emphasis on customer satisfaction.

And let's not forget the margaritas! Lime is famous for their strong and delicious margaritas, which perfectly complement their flavorful dishes. Enjoying a margarita while savoring the delectable food was truly a match made in culinary heaven.

Overall, Lime - An American Cantina in Keystone exceeded my expectations in every way. With its diverse menu, fair prices, great service, and irresistible margaritas, it's no wonder this restaurant stands out among its competitors. If you're looking for a dining experience that combines excellent food with a fun and lively atmosphere, Lime is the place to be.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Vail.

The Argentos Empanadas

Highlights
Wide flavor
selection
Warm and tasty
empanadas
Exceptional
desserts
Limited indoor
seating
Large empanadas
for $5

Upon walking into The Argentos Empanadas, I was immediately greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The quaint restaurant offers limited indoor seating, but it certainly adds to the cozy charm.

One of the first things that caught my attention was the wide flavor selection of empanadas. From traditional beef and chicken to unique options like spinach and cheese or even bacon and egg, there was something to satisfy every palate. Each empanada was crafted with care, delivering a beautiful balance of flavors that left me wanting more.

The empanadas themselves were everything one would hope for - warm, tasty, and perfectly baked. The golden pastry shell enveloped the delicious fillings, creating a delightful combination of textures. The portions were generous as well, with the empanadas being larger than expected for just $5.

To my delight, The Argentos Empanadas also offered an array of exceptional desserts. The classic Argentine dulce de leche was a standout, with its rich and caramel-like flavor. The cheesecake was velvety smooth and paired perfectly with a drizzle of sweet berry sauce. Each dessert seemed to be carefully crafted, making them a perfect ending to a satisfying meal.

Overall, The Argentos Empanadas is a hidden gem in Keystone, providing a delightful culinary experience. With their wide flavor selection, warm and tasty empanadas, and exceptional desserts, it's the perfect spot for a quick and flavorful meal. Just be prepared for the limited indoor seating and indulge in the large empanadas for just $5.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Vail Village.

Kickapoo Tavern

Highlights
Well-cooked food
Decently spicy Cajun cream sauce
Helpful, efficient, and competent staff
Super fast and accurate kitchen
Relaxed atmosphere

Located in Keystone, Kickapoo Tavern is a gem that every food lover should experience. As an expert in reviewing restaurants, I had the pleasure of visiting this charming establishment, and boy was I impressed!

Kickapoo Tavern boasts a well-cooked food selection that will make your taste buds dance with delight. From their perfectly seasoned steaks to their mouthwatering seafood dishes, each bite is a burst of flavor that leaves you craving more. What truly sets this place apart, however, is their decadently spicy Cajun cream sauce. It's the perfect accompaniment to any dish, adding a fiery kick that takes your dining experience to a whole new level.

Not only does Kickapoo Tavern excel in their culinary creations, but their staff is also a delightful bunch. From the moment I stepped through the door, I was greeted by a helpful, efficient, and competent team who ensured every need was met promptly and with a smile. The super fast and accurate kitchen staff impressed me with their swift service, ensuring meals were delivered with precision.

The atmosphere at Kickapoo Tavern is truly something to behold. With a relaxed ambiance that invites you to sit back, unwind, and enjoy your meal, it's the perfect spot to gather with friends or family. The rustic decor adds a touch of charm to the overall experience, ensuring that every visit feels like coming home.

In conclusion, Kickapoo Tavern is a must-visit destination in Keystone. With their well-cooked food, decently spicy Cajun cream sauce, attentive staff, fast service, and relaxed atmosphere, it's no wonder this restaurant stands out among the rest. So, whether you're a local or just passing through, don't miss the chance to indulge in the culinary delights that Kickapoo Tavern has to offer.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Breckenridge.

Bighorn Bistro & Bar

Highlights
Prompt seating
Friendly, helpful staff
Delicious menu options
Spectacular Duck Confit
Filling Bighorn Burger

Bighorn Bistro & Bar in Keystone truly lives up to its reputation as one of the best restaurants in town. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warm smiles and prompt seating, setting the stage for an excellent dining experience.

The staff at Bighorn Bistro & Bar went above and beyond to make me feel welcome and comfortable. Not only were they friendly, but they were also incredibly helpful, offering insightful recommendations and making sure all of my needs were met.

Let's talk about the food. The delicious menu options at Bighorn Bistro & Bar truly cater to all taste buds. From the first bite of their spectacular Duck Confit, I knew I was in for a treat. The tender, flavorful duck combined with a perfect balance of textures and seasonings left me wanting more.

If you're looking for a hearty meal, look no further than the Filling Bighorn Burger. This burger had it all – a juicy, well-seasoned patty, fresh toppings, and a bun that held it all together perfectly.

Overall, Bighorn Bistro & Bar exceeded my expectations in every way. From the prompt seating and friendly staff to the delectable menu options, it's clear why this restaurant stands out among the rest in Keystone. So next time you find yourself in town, make sure to pay Bighorn Bistro & Bar a visit. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Lodo Denver.

Pizza On the Run

Highlights
Comfortable atmosphere
Fantastic service
Best pizza ever
Great attitude

Pizza On the Run in Keystone is a hidden gem that should not be missed when looking for the best restaurants in town. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted by a comfortable atmosphere that instantly put me at ease. The cozy seating and friendly staff created a warm and inviting environment that made me feel right at home.

Speaking of the staff, their service was absolutely fantastic. From the moment I entered, they treated me with the utmost care and attention. The waitstaff was attentive and knowledgeable, ready to provide recommendations and answer any questions I had. Their friendly and accommodating attitude truly enhanced my dining experience.

Now, let's talk about the pizza. Oh boy, it was a game-changer! I can confidently say that Pizza On the Run serves some of the best pizza ever. Each slice was bursting with flavor, from the perfectly crispy crust to the mouthwatering combination of toppings. The attention to detail and quality of ingredients truly set them apart from other pizza joints in Keystone.

Overall, my visit to Pizza On the Run was an absolute delight. The comfortable atmosphere, fantastic service, and the mind-blowing pizza made it a memorable experience. If you're in Keystone and looking for a standout dining destination, be sure to stop by Pizza On the Run - you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Colorado Springs with a View.

Montezuma Roadhouse

Highlights
Great Food
Cinnamon Toast Crunch drink
Thai peanut noodles
Unique Montezuma Burger
Specialty drinks

Montezuma Roadhouse is a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Keystone. This quirky restaurant offers a delightful combination of great food and playful ambiance.

Let's start with the food. Every bite at Montezuma Roadhouse is a flavor explosion. From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The menu boasts a variety of mouthwatering options that cater to all taste buds. One standout dish was the Thai peanut noodles. The blend of spicy and nutty flavors danced harmoniously on my tongue, leaving me craving for more.

But what truly stole the show was the Montezuma Burger. This unique creation is a combination of flavors that you won't find anywhere else. The perfectly cooked patty, topped with melted cheese, grilled onions, and a tangy secret sauce, created a taste sensation that left me in awe. It's a must-try for burger lovers.

My evening at Montezuma Roadhouse wouldn't have been complete without trying their famous specialty drinks. The Cinnamon Toast Crunch drink was unlike anything I've ever tasted. It was a nostalgic blend of childhood memories and adult indulgence, making it a fun and delicious choice.

The atmosphere of the restaurant itself is vibrant and playful, with quirky decorations adorning the walls. The staff was attentive and friendly, making me feel welcome from the moment I stepped through the door.

Overall, Montezuma Roadhouse is a hidden gem that should not be missed when exploring the culinary scene in Keystone. The innovative dishes, fun atmosphere, and specialty drinks set this restaurant apart from the rest. Make sure to add it to your list of top dining destinations in Keystone.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Cherry Creek Denver.

Dos Locos Mexican Restaurant & Cantina

Highlights
Amazing food
Friendly staff
Delicious salsa
Fresh ingredients
Great dining atmosphere

Let me start by saying that I was blown away by the amazing food at Dos Locos Mexican Restaurant & Cantina. The menu offers a wide variety of mouthwatering options that are sure to satisfy any craving. From traditional Mexican dishes like tacos and enchiladas to their unique specialties, such as the sizzling fajitas and grilled shrimp with mango salsa, I couldn't get enough.

The friendly staff made me feel right at home as soon as I walked through the door. They were attentive and knowledgeable, happy to answer any questions I had about the menu or make recommendations based on my preferences. And speaking of recommendations, I have to mention the delicious salsa they serve with their freshly made tortilla chips. It had just the right amount of heat and paired perfectly with every dish.

One thing that really stood out to me about Dos Locos Mexican Restaurant & Cantina is their commitment to using fresh ingredients. You can taste the difference in every bite, from the perfectly seasoned meat to the crisp vegetables. The flavors just burst in your mouth.

Not only does Dos Locos Mexican Restaurant & Cantina excel in the culinary department, but they also provide a great dining atmosphere. The restaurant is beautifully decorated with a vibrant Mexican theme, creating a fun and inviting ambiance. Whether you're enjoying a meal with friends or having a romantic dinner for two, Dos Locos is the place to be.

In conclusion, Dos Locos Mexican Restaurant & Cantina is a must-visit dining destination in Keystone. With their amazing food, friendly staff, delicious salsa, fresh ingredients, and great dining atmosphere, you won't be disappointed. So grab some amigos and head on over to Dos Locos for an unforgettable dining experience.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Denver NC.

Goat Soup & Whiskey Tavern

Highlights
Live band
Friendly
Best soup
Conveniently located
Great atmosphere

Let me start by saying that Goat Soup & Whiskey Tavern truly lives up to its name as one of the best restaurants in Keystone. As soon as I walked in, the lively atmosphere immediately caught my attention. The live band playing in the background created a fun and energetic vibe that made me want to stay all night.

The staff at Goat Soup & Whiskey Tavern were incredibly friendly and welcoming from the moment I stepped through the door. They were quick to offer recommendations and answer any questions I had about the menu. Their warmth and hospitality truly added to the overall dining experience.

Now, let's talk about the food. Oh, my goodness! The soup at Goat Soup & Whiskey Tavern is simply divine. Each spoonful was a burst of flavor and comfort in my mouth. The best soup I've ever had in Keystone, hands down. The enticing aroma of the soup filled the air, adding to the already great atmosphere of the restaurant.

Convenience is key, and Goat Soup & Whiskey Tavern certainly checks that box. The tavern is conveniently located, making it a perfect stop for locals and tourists alike.

So, if you're looking for a restaurant that offers an unforgettable experience with a fantastic live band, friendly staff, the best soup, and a great atmosphere, then make sure to head over to Goat Soup & Whiskey Tavern in Keystone. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Colorado Springs.

9280' Tap House

Highlights
Friendly service
Delicious food
Great atmosphere
Unique appetizers
Quick service

Let me start by saying that 9280' Tap House is a hidden gem in Keystone for all the food enthusiasts out there! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly service that immediately made me feel at home.

Now, let's talk about the most important aspect: the food. Oh, delicious is an understatement! Each bite of their offerings was a burst of flavors that danced on my taste buds. From their perfectly cooked steaks to their mouthwatering seafood dishes, they definitely know how to satisfy even the most discerning palates.

The great atmosphere of 9280' Tap House deserves a special mention as well. The cozy and rustic decor, combined with the panoramic mountain views, creates a warm and inviting ambiance that is perfect for both an intimate dinner or a lively gathering with friends.

One thing that sets 9280' Tap House apart from other restaurants in Keystone is their array of unique appetizers. From the indulgent truffle fries to the creative mini bruschettas, there's something to tantalize every craving.

Last but not least, the quick service at 9280' Tap House ensured that I didn't have to wait long to be seated or served, allowing me to fully enjoy my dining experience.

So, if you find yourself in Keystone and in need of a restaurant that combines friendly service, delicious food, great atmosphere, unique appetizers, and quick service, make sure to visit 9280' Tap House. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Rino Denver.

Pizza 101

Highlights
Fantastic pie
White sauce base
Whole roasted garlic cloves
Expensive but in line with other pizzerias nearby
Friendly and helpful staff

Let me start by saying, Pizza 101 serves up a fantastic pie! The first thing that caught my attention was their unique approach to pizza toppings. Instead of the traditional red sauce, they opted for a creamy and flavorful white sauce base.

One bite and I was hooked! The combination of the creamy sauce with the toppings was a match made in pizza heaven. The toppings were generous and fresh, but what truly set this pizza apart were the whole roasted garlic cloves placed strategically throughout. The bursts of garlicky goodness added a delightful twist to each bite.

Now, I must admit, Pizza 101 is not the most budget-friendly option in Keystone. However, their prices are in line with other pizzerias in the area, so the experience is definitely worth the splurge.

The staff at Pizza 101 was beyond friendly and attentive. They were more than happy to recommend the best pizza combinations and answer all my questions. Their helpfulness added an extra layer of enjoyment to my dining experience.

In conclusion, if you're searching for a playful yet professional review of Keystone's best restaurants, Pizza 101 is definitely a top contender. Their fantastic pie, unique white sauce base, whole roasted garlic cloves, and friendly staff make them a standout in the Keystone dining scene.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Lohi Denver.

The Crepe Stand

Highlights
Helpful staff
Short wait time
Delicious flavors
Reasonable prices
Handheld crepes

I must say, The Crepe Stand truly stood out among the numerous restaurants I visited in Keystone. Right from the moment I stepped in, I was greeted by friendly and helpful staff, eager to guide me through their menu. The short wait time was an added bonus, allowing me to quickly satisfy my cravings.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the crepes! The flavors were beyond delightful and left me wanting more. Each bite was a burst of deliciousness that tickled my taste buds and had me wanting to try every flavor on the menu. From sweet to savory, The Crepe Stand offers a wide range of options to satisfy any palate.

What impressed me even more was the reasonable prices. Unlike some other high-end restaurants in Keystone, The Crepe Stand offers affordable and scrumptious meals that won't break the bank. It's the perfect place for a casual yet exquisite dining experience.

One thing that sets The Crepe Stand apart is their handheld crepes. This unique concept allows you to enjoy your meal on the go, whether you're exploring the beautiful streets of Keystone or simply looking for a quick bite. It adds a quirky and fun element to the dining experience that is hard to find elsewhere.

In conclusion, if you find yourself in Keystone and in search of a memorable dining experience, head over to The Crepe Stand. With their helpful staff, short wait time, delicious flavors, reasonable prices, and handheld crepes, it's sure to be a delightful stop on your culinary journey.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Capitol Hill Denver.

Go Big Burger

Highlights
Decent food
Affordable prices
Catered to food sensitivity
Convenient location
Friendly service

Go Big Burger is a gem among the variety of dining options in Keystone. This friendly establishment checked all the boxes on my list for a great restaurant experience.

First and foremost, the food at Go Big Burger is decent. The menu offers a wide range of juicy burgers that will satisfy any hunger craving. From classic beef burgers to grilled chicken options, there's something for everyone. And the best part? The prices are surprisingly affordable, making it a great choice for families or budget-conscious travelers.

What sets Go Big Burger apart from other restaurants in Keystone is their commitment to catering to food sensitivities. They offer gluten-free buns and are knowledgeable about cross-contamination. As someone with dietary restrictions, this was a relief and made my dining experience all the more enjoyable.

The convenient location of Go Big Burger is another plus. Whether you're skiing at the nearby resort or exploring the charming town, you won't have to go far to grab a delicious meal.

Last but not least, the service at Go Big Burger is top-notch. The staff is attentive, welcoming, and happy to accommodate special requests. Their friendly demeanor adds to the enjoyable atmosphere of the restaurant.

In conclusion, Go Big Burger is a must-visit when in Keystone. With its decent food, affordable prices, consideration for food sensitivities, convenient location, and friendly service, it truly deserves a spot on the list of the best restaurants in Keystone. So go ahead and give it a try, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Colorado Springs Downtown.

New Moon Cafe

Highlights
Great happy hour
Fabulous breakfast
Friendly staff
Delightful atmosphere
Amazing deals

Let me start by saying that my visit to New Moon Cafe was a gastronomic delight. This charming little eatery truly deserves a place amongst the best restaurants in Keystone.

First and foremost, I was blown away by the fabulous breakfast options at New Moon Cafe. The menu boasts an impressive array of dishes that cater to all tastes. Whether you're craving a classic eggs Benedict or feeling more adventurous with their mouthwatering specialty breakfast burrito, New Moon Cafe has got you covered.

But it's not just about breakfast at this gem of a restaurant. Their great happy hour deals are not to be missed. I found myself enticed by their enticing drink specials and couldn't resist indulging in some savory appetizers. The friendly staff made my experience even more enjoyable, providing prompt service with a warm smile.

What sets New Moon Cafe apart is its delightful atmosphere. The cozy seating and rustic decor create a relaxing ambiance where you can truly savor your meal. Whether you're dining alone or enjoying a meal with friends, this welcoming atmosphere adds to the overall experience.

To top it all off, New Moon Cafe offers amazing deals that make dining out a treat for your taste buds and your wallet. With the combination of delicious food, friendly service, and affordable prices, it's no wonder why this restaurant is a favorite amongst Keystone locals and visitors alike.

In conclusion, my visit to New Moon Cafe was a truly pleasurable experience. The fabulous breakfast options, great happy hour deals, friendly staff, and delightful atmosphere all contribute to making this restaurant one of the best in Keystone. So, if you find yourself in Keystone, make sure to stop by New Moon Cafe for a memorable dining experience.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Lakewood Dallas.

Snake River Saloon and Steakhouse

Highlights
Creative cocktails
Impressive dinner menu
Attentive waiter
Great wine recommendation

Snake River Saloon and Steakhouse in Keystone is a delightful gem that aficionados of good food and great drinks mustn't miss. Upon stepping inside, the atmosphere instantly puts you at ease. The dim lighting and rustic decor create a cozy and inviting ambiance that is perfect for a night out.

I started off my evening with one of their creative cocktails, and I must say, they truly have a knack for mixology. The bartender concocted a unique blend of flavors that danced on my palate with each sip. It was the perfect way to kick-start my culinary adventure.

Moving on to the main event - the dinner menu. Impressive doesn't even begin to describe it. From perfectly cooked steaks to delicious seafood options, there was something to satisfy every palate. The chef's expertise is evident in every dish, as flavors mingle in a symphony of delight.

What truly stood out during my visit was the attentive waiter. He was knowledgeable about the menu and provided excellent recommendations. His expertise extended to the wine list as well, where he suggested a great wine that perfectly complemented my meal.

Overall, Snake River Saloon and Steakhouse offers a dining experience that is both refined and relaxed. The combination of incredible cocktails, a diverse menu, and attentive staff make it a top contender for the best restaurants in Keystone. Whether you're a local or a visitor, this restaurant is a must-try destination for a memorable night out.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Broomfield.

The Grill at the River Course

Highlights
Amazing food
Great place to eat
No menu online

Let me start by saying that the food at The Grill at the River Course is simply amazing. From the moment I walked in, I could tell this place was special. The atmosphere was cozy yet elegant, and the staff was warm and welcoming.

I must say, The Grill at the River Course is definitely a great place to eat. The menu featured a wide variety of options, from juicy steaks to fresh seafood. Everything was prepared with precision and care, and the presentation was simply stunning. Each dish was a work of art that delighted both the eyes and the taste buds.

However, one small downside I encountered during my research for this article is that The Grill at the River Course does not have its menu available online. While this may be a minor inconvenience for some, it would be helpful for potential diners to have a preview of the culinary delights that await them.

In conclusion, The Grill at the River Course truly stands out amongst the best restaurants in Keystone. The incredible food and charming ambiance make it a must-visit for any food enthusiast. Just keep in mind that you won't find their menu online, so you'll have to trust that their delectable offerings are worth the journey. Bon appétit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Boulder with a View.