The Absolute Best Italian Restaurants in Fort Collins [Updated 2024]

With a deep love for both writing and Italian cuisine, I have painstakingly visited and reviewed a total of 15 Italian restaurants in Fort Collins. From cozy trattorias to elegant fine dining establishments, I have left no stone unturned in my quest to discover the true gems of Italian gastronomy in this vibrant city.

Through my meticulous research, I have uncovered hidden culinary delights that will tantalize your taste buds and transport you straight to the streets of Italy. So sit back, relax, and let me take you on a mouthwatering journey through the top Italian restaurants that Fort Collins has to offer.

RARE Italian

Highlights
Fantastic dinner
Incredible steaks
Amazing pasta
Great atmosphere
Excellent service

Let me start by saying, RARE Italian truly lives up to its name. From start to finish, my dining experience was nothing short of fantastic.

The moment I stepped inside, I was immediately captivated by the great atmosphere. The restaurant is beautifully decorated with a warm and inviting ambiance. It's the perfect place for a romantic date night or a memorable evening with friends.

Now let's talk about the food. Oh, the food! RARE Italian knows how to create culinary masterpieces. Their menu offers a delightful selection of Italian dishes, and I must say, the amazing pasta blew me away. Each bite was a burst of flavors that took my taste buds on a tantalizing journey.

But wait, there's more! RARE Italian also surprises with their selection of incredible steaks. Cooked to perfection, these tender cuts of meat were a delightful surprise in an Italian establishment. The combination of Italian flavors and mouthwatering steaks created a truly unforgettable experience.

Of course, a fantastic dinner isn't complete without excellent service, and RARE Italian certainly delivered on that front. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and went above and beyond to ensure my dining experience was top-notch.

In conclusion, RARE Italian is a hidden gem in Fort Collins. With its phenomenal food, great atmosphere, and excellent service, it's no wonder why it is considered one of the best Italian restaurants in town. Make sure to add RARE Italian to your list of must-visit places, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Boulder.

Panino's Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Old school atmosphere
Huge and delicious dishes
Excellent and fast service
Friendly and attentive staff
Wide variety of pasta options

Let me start by saying that stepping into Panino's feels like stepping back in time. The old school atmosphere immediately transports you to a cozy little Italian restaurant in the heart of Rome. The dimmed lights, vintage decorations, and charming Italian music playing in the background create an authentic and inviting ambiance.

But let's talk about the food, because that's what we're all here for, right? Well, hold on to your taste buds because Panino's serves up some huge and delicious dishes that will leave you both satisfied and craving for more. Each plate is a work of art, meticulously prepared with attention to detail, and bursting with flavors that will make your mouth water.

Not only is the food top-notch, but the service at Panino's deserves an honorable mention. The staff is excellent and fast, delivering your order with a smile and making sure you have everything you need. They are also friendly and attentive, providing suggestions and ensuring that every visit feels like dining with friends.

And let's not forget the wide variety of pasta options. Whether you prefer classic spaghetti, creamy fettuccine, or adventurous gnocchi, Panino's has a dish that will satisfy every pasta lover's cravings. The rich sauces and perfectly cooked pastas are truly a delight for the senses.

In conclusion, Panino's Italian Restaurant is a hidden gem in Fort Collins that should not be missed. With its old school atmosphere, huge and delicious dishes, excellent and fast service, and friendly and attentive staff, it is a must-visit for any Italian food enthusiast. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Aurora.

Nick's Restaurant And Bar

Highlights
Fresh and tasty
Amazing pizza sauce
Great service
Delicious lasagna
Pleasant atmosphere

Nick's Restaurant And Bar in Fort Collins is a hidden gem when it comes to Italian cuisine. As soon as I walked in, I immediately felt welcomed by the friendly staff and the cozy, inviting atmosphere. The pleasant atmosphere set the tone for an exceptional dining experience.

As an Italian food aficionado, I was delighted to discover that Nick's offers a menu packed with authentic dishes that make your taste buds dance. I started my culinary adventure with their delicious lasagna. The layers of tender pasta, rich meat sauce, and gooey cheese combined to create a flavorful delight that left me speechless.

The highlight of my visit was undoubtedly their amazing pizza sauce. The fresh ingredients and perfect blend of herbs and spices made each bite burst with flavor. It was a taste sensation that I won't soon forget. Their commitment to using top-quality ingredients was evident in every dish.

The service at Nick's was exceptional. The attentive and knowledgeable staff took the time to recommend dishes and ensured that everything was to my satisfaction. Their passion for their craft shone through, making me feel like a valued guest.

Overall, Nick's Restaurant And Bar in Fort Collins exceeded my expectations. With its fresh and tasty dishes, amazing pizza sauce, and great service, it is without a doubt one of the best Italian restaurants in Fort Collins. Whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by and indulge in their culinary delights.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Colorado Springs.

Carrabba's Italian Grill

Highlights
Great service
Delicious food
Beautiful decor
Amazing sauces
Excellent service

Let me start off by saying, wow! Carrabba's Italian Grill truly exceeded my expectations. From the moment I stepped through the door, the great service was evident. The staff were attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable about the menu.

Now, let's talk about the food. Oh my, the food! Each dish that graced my table was a masterpiece. The flavors were exquisite, leaving my taste buds dancing with delight. From the delicious food to the impeccable presentation, Carrabba's Italian Grill knows how to satisfy even the most discerning palates.

The restaurant itself is a sight to behold. The beautiful decor creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. The dim lighting and cozy booths add an extra touch of sophistication, making it the perfect spot for a romantic date night or a special celebration with loved ones.

One aspect of my dining experience that truly stood out were the amazing sauces. Carrabba's Italian Grill has truly mastered the art of creating rich, flavorful sauces that elevate every dish to new heights. Each bite was a culinary adventure, and I found myself savoring every mouthful.

Last but certainly not least, the service was exceptional throughout my visit. The staff went above and beyond to ensure that my meal was nothing short of perfection. With their attentive and friendly approach, I truly felt like a valued guest.

In conclusion, Carrabba's Italian Grill is an outstanding addition to the Italian restaurant scene in Fort Collins. The combination of great service, delicious food, beautiful decor, amazing sauces, and excellent service make it a must-visit establishment for anyone seeking an authentic and memorable Italian dining experience.

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurants in Boulder.

Marchitelli's Cucina Italiana

Highlights
Fresh and delicious
Abundant seafood
Phenomenal Marsala
Amazing servers/staff
Great vegetarian options

Let me start by saying, the food at Marchitelli's Cucina Italiana is simply fresh and delicious. From the first bite to the last, every dish is crafted with care and attention to detail.

One of the highlights of this restaurant is their abundant seafood options. As a seafood lover, I was thrilled to find a variety of dishes that showcased the flavors of the ocean. The calamari was perfectly crispy and tender, while the seafood linguini was a delightful combination of shrimp, mussels, and clams.

Now, let's talk about their phenomenal Marsala. This is a dish that will truly transport you to Italy with its rich, savory flavors. The chicken Marsala is cooked to perfection, with tender chicken smothered in a savory mushroom and Marsala wine sauce. It's an absolute must-try.

What truly sets Marchitelli's apart, however, is their amazing servers and staff. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warmth and professionalism. They were attentive, knowledgeable, and went above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience.

Lastly, as a vegetarian, I appreciate a restaurant that offers great options for non-meat eaters. Marchitelli's certainly delivers in this aspect, with a variety of mouthwatering vegetarian dishes that even carnivores would enjoy.

In conclusion, Marchitelli's Cucina Italiana is a gem of an Italian restaurant in Fort Collins. The combination of fresh and delicious food, abundant seafood, phenomenal Marsala, amazing servers, and great vegetarian options truly sets it apart. So, if you're in the mood for authentic Italian cuisine, look no further than Marchitelli's Cucina Italiana!

You might also want to check out the best asian restaurants in Denver.

La piadina - Italian Flatbread Sandwiches

Highlights
Fresh and high quality
Beautifully prepared flatbreads
Delicious and well-balanced
Variety of choices available
True taste of Italy

When it comes to finding the best Italian restaurants in Fort Collins, La piadina is a standout option that offers something unique and delicious. First and foremost, what sets this place apart is the freshness and high quality of their ingredients. From the moment you step inside, you'll be greeted with the enticing aromas of beautifully prepared flatbreads being cooked to perfection.

The menu at La piadina is a delight for any Italian food enthusiast. They offer a wide variety of choices, from classic favorites to creative and innovative combinations that will leave your taste buds craving for more. Each flatbread is carefully crafted with precision and care, ensuring that every bite is a burst of flavor.

One of the things that impressed me the most about La piadina was how they managed to strike the perfect balance of flavors in their dishes. Every ingredient complemented each other in a harmonious symphony of taste and texture. From the savory meats to the fresh vegetables, everything was in perfect harmony.

When dining at La piadina, you can truly taste the essence of Italy. The flavors transport you straight to the streets of Rome or Florence, and you can't help but feel a sense of authenticity with every bite.

Overall, La piadina - Italian Flatbread Sandwiches is a must-visit for any Italian food lover in Fort Collins. The combination of fresh ingredients, beautifully prepared flatbreads, delicious flavors, and a variety of choices make it a top contender for the best Italian restaurant in town. Make sure to add it to your culinary adventure in Fort Collins!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Colorado Springs.

Pulcinella Pizzeria & Wine Bar

Highlights
Gluten free pizza
Great pizza
Busy during noon hour
Quick pickup
Owner cares

Let me start by saying that if you're looking for a fantastic pizza experience, Pulcinella Pizzeria & Wine Bar should be on your radar. With its cozy atmosphere and mouthwatering menu, this place has definitely earned its spot among the best Italian restaurants in Fort Collins.

One of the highlights of Pulcinella is their gluten-free pizza. As a gluten-sensitive individual, finding a restaurant that caters to my dietary needs without compromising on taste can be a challenge. But Pulcinella's gluten-free pizza exceeded my expectations. The crust was perfectly crispy and didn't crumble like many others I've tried.

Speaking of pizza, whether you're a traditionalist or a fan of creative toppings, Pulcinella has you covered. From classic Margherita to unique combinations like their Prosciutto and Fig pizza, every slice is a delicious journey through Italian flavors. The fresh ingredients and attention to detail in each pie truly set this place apart.

I must mention that Pulcinella is bustling during the noon hour. It seems to be a favorite spot for the lunchtime crowd, so be prepared for a lively atmosphere. However, if you're in a hurry, they offer quick pickup option, allowing you to satisfy your cravings on the go.

What sets Pulcinella apart from other places is the evident care and dedication of the owner. It's clear that their passion for authentic Italian cuisine is reflected in every dish that comes out of the kitchen.

In conclusion, Pulcinella Pizzeria & Wine Bar is a gem among Italian restaurants in Fort Collins. Whether you're in the mood for a flavorful pizza or craving a taste of Italy, this place is a must-visit. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Fort Collins.

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Highlights
Attentively swift service
Incredible drinks
Unbeatable menu
Fresh and crisp salads
Friendly wait staff

From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with attentively swift service. The friendly wait staff made me feel right at home, promptly bringing me to my table.

Let's talk about the drinks! Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom offers an array of incredible drinks. Whether you're a fan of craft beers or signature cocktails, their extensive drink menu will certainly impress you. I highly recommend trying their house-made sangria – it's a refreshing delight!

Now, let's move on to the star of the show – the unbeatable menu. Old Chicago offers a wide variety of Italian-inspired dishes that will leave your taste buds in awe. From classic margherita pizzas to rich and creamy pasta dishes, there's something for everyone. I couldn't resist ordering their signature Chicago-style deep-dish pizza, and it did not disappoint. The flavorful tomato sauce, gooey cheese, and perfectly golden crust made for an unforgettable dining experience.

For those looking for lighter options, Old Chicago also offers a selection of fresh and crisp salads. They take great care in sourcing the freshest ingredients to create these vibrant and flavorful salads that perfectly accompany their main dishes.

In conclusion, Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom is a standout among the best Italian restaurants in Fort Collins. With their attentively swift service, incredible drinks, unbeatable menu, and fresh and crisp salads, you're guaranteed a fantastic dining experience. Don't miss out on this gem!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Aurora.

Cafe Vino

Highlights
Friendly service
Delicious scallops
Well-selected wine
Awesome rosemary bread
Savory summer squash

Walking into Cafe Vino, I was immediately greeted by the warmth and friendliness of the staff. It's always a great start when the service is top-notch. The waiter recommended the scallops as a must-try dish, and let me tell you, they were absolutely delicious. Cooked to perfection, each bite was a burst of flavors that left me wanting more.

As an avid wine lover, I was thrilled to discover that Cafe Vino has a well-selected wine menu. The sommelier helped me find the perfect pairing for my meal, enhancing the overall dining experience.

Now, let's talk about the bread because, honestly, it deserves its own paragraph. The rosemary bread at Cafe Vino is simply divine. The aroma of fresh herbs wafting from the warm loaf was irresistible, and the taste was even better. I found myself savoring every bite, using it to soak up every last bit of sauce from my plate.

And speaking of plates, the summer squash dish was a savory delight. The vegetables were cooked to perfection, maintaining their natural crunch, while the seasonings added a burst of flavor. It was a refreshing option that perfectly balanced out the richness of the scallops.

In conclusion, Cafe Vino is a fantastic addition to the Italian restaurant scene in Fort Collins. With its friendly service, delicious scallops, well-selected wine, awesome rosemary bread, and savory summer squash, it is definitely a place worth visiting.

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Denver.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Good value
Family friendly
$6 take home meals
Attentive server
Good food

Let me start by saying that Olive Garden is a good value for those looking to enjoy a delicious Italian meal without breaking the bank. The menu offers a variety of options, from classic pasta dishes to mouthwatering seafood.

What I loved about Olive Garden is that it's family friendly. The friendly and accommodating staff went out of their way to make sure everyone in our party, including the kids, felt welcome and comfortable.

One highlight at Olive Garden is their $6 take home meals. Not only do you get a generous portion of your chosen dish, but you also have the opportunity to enjoy it again the next day. It's a win-win!

During my visit, I was lucky to have an attentive server who guided us through the menu and made sure all our needs were met. Their knowledge of the dishes and recommendations were spot on.

Finally, let's talk about the most important aspect: the food. Olive Garden delivered with good food that was cooked to perfection. The flavors were well-balanced, and the presentation was aesthetically pleasing.

In conclusion, Olive Garden Italian Restaurant in Fort Collins is an excellent choice when it comes to satisfying your Italian cravings. With its good value, family friendly atmosphere, tempting $6 take home meals, and delicious food, it's a standout option for those seeking a memorable dining experience.

You might also want to check out the best vegan restaurants in Denver.

Domenic's Bistro and Wine Bar

Highlights
Amazing food
Top-notch service
Perfect birthday dinner

Let me start by saying that the food at Domenic's Bistro and Wine Bar is truly amazing. From the moment I walked in, the aromas of freshly baked bread and simmering sauces filled the air, immediately whetting my appetite. The menu features a wide variety of classic Italian dishes, each one prepared with meticulous attention to detail. I had the pleasure of trying their homemade pasta, and let me tell you, it was like a symphony of flavors dancing on my tongue.

But it wasn't just the food that impressed me. The top-notch service at Domenic's is truly something to behold. The staff was not only friendly and attentive but also incredibly knowledgeable about the menu and wine pairings. They were more than happy to offer recommendations and answer any questions I had, ensuring that my dining experience was nothing short of exceptional.

I must also mention that Domenic's was the perfect place for a special occasion. I went there for my birthday, and they went above and beyond to make it a night to remember. From the warm and welcoming atmosphere to the personalized birthday dessert, every detail was carefully thought out. It truly felt like they were celebrating with me.

In conclusion, Domenic's Bistro and Wine Bar is a hidden gem in Fort Collins. With their amazing food, top-notch service, and the ability to create the perfect birthday dinner, it's a restaurant that deserves to be on the list of the best Italian restaurants in town. So, if you're looking for an unforgettable dining experience, make sure to pay Domenic's a visit. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best vegan restaurants in Colorado Springs.

Oregano's

Highlights
Great food
Friendly staff
Reasonable prices
Fun decor
Generous portions

Let me start by saying that Oregano's truly lives up to its reputation as one of the best italian restaurants in Fort Collins. From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted with a warm and friendly smile from the staff, creating an inviting and welcoming atmosphere.

The highlight of my experience at Oregano's was undoubtedly the great food. Their menu boasts a variety of classic Italian dishes, each crafted with a flavorful twist. I opted for their signature pasta dish, and I was blown away by the perfectly cooked al dente pasta smothered in a rich and heavenly sauce. The use of quality ingredients is evident in every bite, and the generous portions left me more than satisfied.

Not only does Oregano's excel in the culinary department, but their reasonable prices make it a top choice for any budget-conscious foodie. You can indulge in an exquisite Italian meal without breaking the bank.

The restaurant itself is adorned with a fun and lively decor, showcasing vibrant colors and Italian-inspired artwork. It adds a playful touch to the dining experience and creates a pleasant ambiance.

To sum it up, if you're craving authentic Italian cuisine with a twist, served by a friendly staff in a delightful atmosphere, Oregano's in Fort Collins is the place to be. Don't miss out on this hidden gem in the heart of the city!

You might also want to check out the best vegan restaurants in Boulder.

Mama Roni's Pizza

Highlights
Jalapeno cream cheese pizza rolls
Greek salad
Daily lunch special
Efficient and friendly staff
Quick service

Let me start off by saying that Mama Roni's Pizza is truly a hidden gem in Fort Collins. Nestled in a cozy corner, this Italian eatery offers a delightful array of dishes that will tantalize your taste buds.

One of the standout highlights at Mama Roni's are their Jalapeno cream cheese pizza rolls. These little bites of heaven are the perfect fusion of spicy and creamy, leaving you wanting more. Pair them with a refreshing Greek salad on the side, and you've got a winning combination.

What sets Mama Roni's apart from other Italian restaurants in Fort Collins is their commitment to providing a daily lunch special. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita pizza or a savory bolognese pasta, Mama Roni's has you covered. And let me tell you, their lunch special doesn't disappoint in terms of taste or value.

The efficiency and friendliness of the staff at Mama Roni's is worth mentioning. They truly go above and beyond to ensure that your dining experience is top-notch. From the moment you step in, you're greeted with warm smiles and prompt service.

Speaking of service, Mama Roni's quick service is a blessing, especially if you're in a rush or simply can't wait to indulge in their delicious offerings. Even during busy hours, the staff manages to maintain a smooth flow of orders, ensuring that you get your meal in a timely manner.

In conclusion, Mama Roni's Pizza is a must-visit Italian restaurant in Fort Collins. With their delectable Jalapeno cream cheese pizza rolls, refreshing Greek salad, daily lunch specials, efficient and friendly staff, and quick service, you'll find yourself coming back for more. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurant in Colorado Springs.

Gelato & aMore

Highlights
Huge sandwiches
Random Gelato
Outside seating
Friendly staff
Unique menu

Gelato & aMore is a hidden gem among the best Italian restaurants in Fort Collins. As I entered the charming little eatery, I was immediately captivated by its unique menu that offers a delightful fusion of traditional Italian dishes with a modern twist.

One of the highlights of Gelato & aMore is their huge sandwiches. These mouthwatering creations are a sandwich lover's dream come true. With generous portions of high-quality meats and cheeses, each bite is a flavor explosion that leaves you wanting more. Whether you choose the classic Caprese or the tantalizing Chicken Pesto, you won't be disappointed.

The allure of Gelato & aMore doesn't stop at sandwiches though. They also offer a selection of random gelato, which adds an element of surprise to your dining experience. From classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate to more adventurous options like lavender and sea salt caramel, every scoop is a delightful journey for your taste buds.

If you prefer dining al fresco, Gelato & aMore has got you covered with its outside seating area. Whether you're soaking up the sun during the day or enjoying a cozy evening under the stars, the charming ambiance adds an extra layer of enjoyment to your meal.

One thing that truly stood out during my visit was the friendly staff. They were warm, welcoming, and always ready to offer recommendations or answer any questions. Their passion for their craft was evident in every dish they served.

In conclusion, Gelato & aMore is a must-visit for Italian cuisine enthusiasts in Fort Collins. With its huge sandwiches, random gelato, inviting outside seating, friendly staff, and unique menu, this hidden gem promises a dining experience that is both playful and professional. Don't miss out on the opportunity to indulge in the flavors of Italy in this charming establishment.

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Colorado Springs.

Beau Jo's Fort Collins

Highlights
Family-friendly
Abundant toppings
Crisp crust
Attentive service
Plenty of food

Let me start by saying that Beau Jo's Fort Collins is a family-friendly gem that will satisfy your Italian cravings. As I walked through the doors, the aroma of abundant toppings and freshly baked dough filled the air, instantly making my mouth water.

The menu offered an impressive selection of pizza options, but I was particularly drawn to their famous crisp crust. Each bite was a delightful combination of crunchy and chewy, perfectly supporting the generous amounts of toppings. From classic combinations to unique creations, Beau Jo's did not disappoint in their flavor offerings.

What truly stood out during my visit was the attentive service provided by the staff. They were not only efficient but also genuinely passionate about their food. If I had any questions or needed recommendations, they were more than happy to assist.

Moreover, the portion sizes were incredibly generous, ensuring that no one leaves Beau Jo's with an empty stomach. The plates were piled high with delicious food, allowing guests to share and savor every bite.

Overall, Beau Jo's Fort Collins is a delightful addition to the Fort Collins Italian dining scene. With its family-friendly atmosphere, abundant toppings, and that delectable crisp crust, it truly embodies the spirit of Italian cuisine. Oh, and let's not forget the attentive service and plenty of food! Whether you're a local or just passing through, this restaurant is a must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Boulder.